Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Liturgies coptes - Ensemble David

Les observateurs occasionnels du Moyen Orient peuvent être excuses de croire que les coptes étaient une minorité respectée jusqu’à la chute de Hosni Mubarak. En réalité, les coptes sont opprimés depuis l’implantation de l’Islam en Egypte et au Soudan. Le pape Chenouda III, chef de l’Église copte a été mis en résidence surveillée entre 1981 et 1985. Plus récemment, le soi-disant « printemps arabe » a résulté dans une série d’attaques contre des églises et personnalités coptes. Un jour, le Monde comprendra que la démocratie et les droits de l’homme, ainsi comme toute autre idée de modernité, ne sont pas compatibles avec le voile Islamique…


Dans ce contexte, l’album Liturgies coptes de l’Ensemble David, production de l’Institut du MondeArabe, est un rappel du danger subi par les communautés coptes au Moyen Orient. 


Saturday, October 5, 2013

Vertigo - Alfred Hitchcock

When it was released in 1958, Vertigo received mixed critics and barely broke even. In 2012, it replaced Citizen Kane "as the best movie of all time" in the Sight & Sound critics poll. The value of the lists including  the best (or worst) movies is in the eyes of the beholder. The fact is, though, that Vertigo has been rehabilitated since Alfred Hitchcock filmed it.

I found Vertigo slow and excesively long. The plot is quite decent but, as is usually the case in movies, Hitchcock tries to solve everything in the last 15 minutes after 2 hours of forgetable scenes that barely provide any information. I tend to agree with the contemporaneous critics of the movie, which didn't see anything innovative in Vertigo. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to find anything online which could help me understand why Vertigo became a cult movie either. For once, Wikipedia didn't provide any useful information, and most of the critiques that I came across on IMDB or Rotten Tomatoes just tell me that I have to choose between liking the movie or feel like an idiot -the critiques that didn't put me in that juncture were spoilers. 

I can only guess that Vertigo is currently considered a masterpiece because professional critics started saying so and then the crowd followed. Vertigo has all the things that critics love about movies: some subtle sexual messages (which go mostly unadverted by modern audiences), a twisted plot, and an amibguous ending. 

The fact that Vertigo is considered a masterpiece is, I guess, one of the reasons you should watch it. But don't expect too much about it.


Thursday, October 3, 2013

The Syrian Orthodox Church of Antioch - Choir members of churches Saint-George and Saint-Ephraim, Aleppo

As I write, Syria is in the process of being destroyed. A protracted civil war, weapons of mass destruction, and sectarism will likely result in the death of a country. As a graduate student, I spent one of the happiest periods in my life in Syria. By the end of my period there, I had found four good friends who are likely endangered: a Kurd, a Christian, an Alaouite, and a Jewish Armenian. I haven't heard from them since the "Arab Spring" arrived to Syria and I can only hope that they and their families will eventually escape the terror and will find a safe haven.

If Syria survives as a single country, it will be after years, maybe decades of sectarian conflict. At the end, one group will prevail after killing and subjugating all its rivals. As a tribute to the current diversity of Syria, I would like to invite the readers of this blog to listen to The Syrian Orthodox Church of Antioch, a production by the coir members of the churches of Saint-George and Saint-Ephraim from Aleppo, which is probably the most Arab and Christian city of the entire country. The album is available here.

Monday, September 30, 2013

In the Court of the Crimson King - King Crimson

Rock & roll and pop are the direct sons of blues. If you listen carefully, you can easily track the structure of most rock and pop songs to the blues' basic melody. When rock & roll was in its infancy, however, some bands were influenced by jazz rather than by blues. Progressive rock and heavy metal are directly linked to jazz: a guitar virtuoso is closer to Charlie Parker or Thelonious Monk than it might seem. 

The ultimate example of how progressive rock is linked to jazz is King Crimson and their debut album, In the Court of the Crimson King, which is probably the first progressive rock recording in the "proper" sense of the term. Noise and lyrics apart, this KC concert in 1969 can perfectly pass as a jazz show. In addition to its excellent musical quality, In the Court of the Crimson King is an extremely important album in the history of music because it created a clear distinction between the bands who claimed their ascent from blues (pop, light rock) and the children of jazz (heavy metal, progressive). Since then, few bands, with the remarkable exception of Pink Floyd, have tried to bridge the gap between the two traditions of modern music, forget about doing it successfully. 

There is a reason why late 1960's bands like KC decided to emulate jazz rather than blues: jazz is much more complicated and structured than blues, and offers more possibilities to experiment and improvise live. Jazz allows musicians to push music to its limits: scales, tempos and improvisations are subject to the imagination and ability of the interpreter. The link between jazz and progressive rock is the result of hyperactive, hypercreative, and hyper-high musicians who got tired of the structure of "Hey Jude". 

Since their first album, KC has done exactly that: push the very concept of music to its last limits. Though the band is now pretty much in the mainstream, the reality is that every production of King Crimson is an experiment, some of which are quite decent, and some of which are a complete disaster. There are two problems with being a continuous experimentation: the first one is that people eventually get tired of experimenting; that explains why KC doesn't really exist as a band. KC dissolves every now and then because they get tired of Robert Fripp's ideas. KC is, in fact, Robert Fripp and the musicians who share his conception of music at a given moment. The second problem with being an experiment-in-the-making permanently is that your fan base becomes very narrow and composed mostly of groupies who really don't have any criteria. Most people wouldn't believe that this song and this song are performed by the same band, and in fact they arent: KC is just a label for Robert Fripp's creativity and escort musicians. Fans who say they like "everything" or "most" of what KC produced don't realize that the band have produced very contradictory pieces in their 40+ years of trajectory.


Friday, September 27, 2013

Re - Café Tacvba

Se ha vuelto un lugar común decir que México cambió en 1994: el levantamiento zapatista, el asesinato de Colosio, la quiebra del país, la entrada en vigor del TLCAN, y la elección de Ernesto Zedillo, que hasta la fecha es el único presidente mexicano que ha reconocido que ganó en condiciones inequitativas, se citan como el conjunto de momentos que llevaron a la transformación del país. Los historiadores, y cada vez más los periodistas y los comentócratas, tienen fama de hacer observaciones tan mesiánicas como esas. Aún si asumimos que el país realmente cambió gracias a uno o a todos esos acontecimientos, es obvio que las condiciones objetivas y subjetivas que llevaron a ellos tomaron mucho para concretarse: hay reportes de grupos guerrilleros entrenando en el sureste desde los 80; el TLCAN se negoció en 6 años, y el PRI, y con él la sociedad mexicana, fue cambiando lenta y paulatimanente desde su creación en 1929. Los cambios históricos no ocurren de un día a otro: empiezan sin que nos demos cuenta y después a algún listo se le ocurre decir que, en una fecha específica, un acontecimiento llevó a un cambio profundo de las cosas.

Con la música es más fácil. Los discos nos permiten (o nos permitían) aseverar con  exactitud cuándo un movimiento artístico, un país, o un artista, cambia. Y así, podemos afirmar, sin temor a equivocarnos, que el rock mexicano cambió en 1994. En ese año, Caifanes sacó El Nervio del Volcán, que a la postre sería su último disco, y Café Tacvba sacó Re, su segunda producción discográfica. En 1994 se efectuó el relevo generacional y de clase del rock mexicano: Saúl Hernández, el chavo banda de la Colonia Guerrero, fue revelado por los chavos universitarios de Ciudad Satélite, ese lugar cuyos primeros residentes fueron, según Carlos Monsiváis, la primera generación de norteamericanos nacidos en México. Desde entonces, ninguna banda de estrato social bajo ha triunfado a gran escala. Café Tacvba puso de moda las cajas de sonido. Así, con el cambio generacional, murió el único intento serio que han hecho los músicos mexicanos de ser virtuoso con los instrumentos: Lino Nava y Marcóvich le dieron paso a los hermanos Rangel y sus imitadores que, si bien no están mal, no son un dechado de virtudes. Con Re, Café Tacvba puso el ejemplo de la música que debía hacerse para ganarse a la clase media (aspiracional y auténtica) y alta y el tipo de gente que tiene posibilidades de triunfar: los hipsters. 

En alguna ocasión leí o escuché que, en los años 60, El Tri empezó a cantar lo que la gente de México, para que, veinte años después, Caifanes empezara a interpretar lo que esa misma gente sentía. En Re, Café Tacvba sintetizó ambas cosas. Con Re, Café Tacvba se afianzó como la única banda mexicana que no sentía vergüenza de ponerse pantalones de mezclilla sin penacho (Caifanes) ni necesidad de gritar como un histérico las mismas necedades durante 30 años (El Tri). Nadie, ni siquiera el propio Café Tacvba, ha sintetizado tan bien todas las corrientes del rock comercial mexicano desde entonces y, a la luz de la evolución musical del propio Café Tacvba, es evidente que ellos no lo van a hacer en lo que les queda de carrera. 

Recientemente, la versión en inglés de Rolling Stone catalogó a Re como el mejor disco de rock latino de la Historia. Y de hecho, desde que salió, se ha dicho que lo mejor de Re es la forma en que combina rock-pop con diversos ritmos musicales populares mexicanos como la tambora, el bolero, y la norteña, así como referencias al pasado prehispánico del país (verbigracia "El fin de la infancia", "Madrugal", obviamente "Ingrata", y "El Tlatoani del barrio"). A mí me gusta plantear esa aseveración de una forma un poco diferente: Re muestra, como en su momento lo hizo "La Negra Tomasa" de Caifanes, o Molotov cantando canciones de José José, que los mexicanos no somos rockeros. Ni siquiera pop-rockeros. Si una banda mexicana quiere triunfar comercialmente, tiene que hacer una mezcla con algún ritmo tradicional (por suerte, la cultura tradicional es mexicana es tan rica que hay mucho de dónde escoger sin repetirse o copiar demasiado a otras bandas), hacer un cóver de una canción tradicional o de los años 50-60 (juego que Café Tacvba entendió a la perfección, como demuestra su Avalancha de Éxitos), incluir términos y juegos de palabras que sólo entienden los mexicanos o, ya si de plano no  da la creatividad, tomarse fotos en algún palenque de Paquita la del Barrio. Una banda que haga referencia exclusivamente al rock como se entiende en Estados Unidos y Europa está destinada a fracasar rotundamente o, en el mejor de los casos, a ser una banda de una canción y punto. 

Re es un buen disco, el mejor que ha hecho Café Tacvba si excluimos su Unplugged, que no es otra cosa que una interpretación acúsitca del propio Re... En cierta forma, y gracias a las combinaciones que hace de rock-pop con ritmos tradicionales mexicanos, es una excelente introducción a la música mexicana para extranjeros o para clasemedieros que no salen mucho de la ciudad. Involuntariamente, Re es el equivalente a los últimos libros de Carlos Fuentes, destinados más a los extranjeros que a los propios mexicanos.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Flamenco Arabe 2 - Hossam Ramzy & José Luis Montón

Flamenco Arabe 2 pretends to fusion José Luis Montón's flamenco guitar with the talent of Hossam Ramzy playing Arabic traditional instruments. Both Montón and Ramzy are extremely talented musicians. For what it's worth, Ramzy played with Peter Gabriel prior to the recording of Flamenco Arabe 2.

For some reason, I found this album tremendously disappointing. There are three possible non-excluding reasons for that: the first reason is that, after the work of Michel Camilo and Tomatito, my standards for flamenco-fussion are very high. The second reason is that I'm probably too tired of listening Mediterranean music. I'm going to give it a break, go back to King Crimson for a couple of weeks, and then come back. The third reason is that Flamenco Arabe 2 sounds like any modern Arabic music album. We all know that Arabic countries have had tremendous problems dealing with modernity in all aspects, and music is not the exceptions. For most Arabic musicians, modernity means using the same instruments that have been played in the region for the last 500 years, only faster and with some Western arrangements. And that's the problem with this album: it's too Arabic, up to the point where the influence of flamenco is lost. Nightclubs in Marrakech, Tunis, or El Cairo can play this or any other album in the top-100; listeners will not notice the difference. This blog makes a similar statement about this album, though using a more subtle style. 

The best song of the album is probably "Arena", written by José Luis Montón, who says the following about it:

"With this Cadiz rhythm full of warmth, I try to twin two towns and two sands: sea and desert." 


The Chicano - Edward Simmen

The best way to pave a way in America's academic life is to come up with a definition for a term that has remained loosely defined. How many academics have achieved tenure for providing a definition for words like "globalization", "governance", "development", or "Renaissance", just to mention a few examples?

Ed Simmen became a worldwide reference for Chicano affairs with his book The Chicano: From Caricature to Self-Portrait. After publishing The Chicano, Simmen became a reference on Hispanic affairs, and he moved to Mexico, where he became a reference on American immigrants affairs... Simmen's cast a long shadow, as this text on Chicano affairs from the late 1980's shows. 

The reason why The Chicano was fundamental for both Simmen's career and Hispanic studies in general is that Simmen provided the first operational definition of chicano in this book. According to Simmen, a chicano can be defined as "a dissatisfied American of Mexican descent whose ideas regarding his position in the social and economic order are, in general, considered to be liberal or radical and whose statements and actions are often extreme and sometimes violent (p. xiii)." Simmen crafted this definition in 1971. It is worth noting that, a couple of years later, Reagan would famously declare that "Hispanics [the word 'chicano' is no longer used as it is considered derogatory] are conservative, they just don't know it."

Remarkably, The Chicano is not an academic book, but a collection of short stories. The fact that a linguist collecting short stories was able to set the terms of the debate on what chicanos are is a testimony of the lack of interest that this group arose among mainstream academia in the United States. Similar to North of the Rio Grande, which collects a series of short stories about Mexicans in the United States, The Chicano presents a number of short-stories on Mexican-Americans. The quality of the texts is heterogeneous: big names in American literature such as Jack London ("The Mexican"), John Steinbeck ("The Flight"), and Ray Bradbury ("The Wonderful Ice Cream Suit") join semi-anonymous and sometimes amateurish writers in a single book. I particularly found most of the stories naive and full of stereotypes. Sadly, the first stories, written the late 1860's and 1930 show Mexican-Americans as brave and gallant men ready to run away with their beloved as soon as possible, while the latest stories, written between the end of World War II and the late 1960's are full of stereotypes: Mexicans (and Mexican-Americans) are lazy, ugly, dirty, and all they do is drink tequila and listen mariachis...

After moving to Mexico, Simmen published a third book called Gringos in Mexico, which is (you guessed right!), a collection of short stories written by Americans living in Mexico. Simmen didn't have enough time to issue a fourth book collecting short stories written by Mexicans about Americans in Mexico. Life is sometimes too short...